@holymonolith

1 year ago

Why does Arthur Morgan Win in my opinion?

Strength: Arthur Morgan. Reason: Arthur has way more strength feats compared to ellie. some of these include His fighting skills, In game, arthur is shown to be able to lift large animals up, such as deer, and 210 pound guys over his shoulder. He beat several people, Including tommy, Whilst it's true arthur went with a cheap ball shot, He had no choice, as he was already at a disadvantage. He also beat several others before his fight with tommy, and even beat bertram, which despite his mental Retardness, Was extremely strong. there's even one scene where he lifts up a guy several feet above his head. Arthur also beat another big guy, An odriscol that tried to jump him, and when he was captured in guarma, beat up a big cuban dude. (his captor)

Speed: Ellie. Self Explantory.

Agility: Ellie. Self Explanatory.

IQ: Most people assume Ellie is more intelligent, which isn't true at all. Both ellie and arthur had no education whatsoever, keep in mind that IQ isn't solely based on knowing math, science, etc. it's just well.. how smart you are.

Battle IQ: Arthur. He's a way better tactical leader (whatever you call it) And was the right hand man of dutch can der linde, Whivh he assisted with in planning mutiple robberies, and Crimes. Ellie on the other hand doesn't plan, and just... well.. yeah..

Durability: Arthur, survived a shotgun to the shoulder, in close range to his other organs due to it being pressed right up against it, and It being a shotgun, cuz spread. The only canon injury ellie got was getting imapled by a sharp tree branch, she wasn't there for long and managed to stitch herself up almost instantly after, Whilst arthur spent a hour or so traveling to th camp, with two gunshot wounds in close range to his vital organs.

Skills: Arthur.

Stamina: Arthur, can run for longer periods of time, in and out of combat.

Combat: Arthur, ellie sucks at H2H and takes around 12 hits or so with her switchblade before killing somrone.


if you still simp for ellie, Idk what to tell you.

|