Naihanchi Comparison - Shorin-Ryu vs KishimotoDi #karate #shorinryu #kishimotodi #kata #martialarts

Due to YouTube's recent changes on high resolution playback, it is sadly impossible to play high-resolution video with audio without client-side JavaScript enabled. Switch to SD quality or enable JavaScript to play your video with audio.

High Definition Standard Definition

Stats For Nerds

Theater

Video id : SSU5GFghjm0
ImmersiveAmbientModecolor: #d8dedc (color 1)
Video Format : (720p) openh264 ( https://github.com/cisco/openh264) mp4a.40.2 | 44100Hz
Audio Format: 140 ( High )
PokeEncryptID: 1ee81d019d3f742e0594512748e4be33dffdec77bffdd5c518e106902b989dc20e4bd0af74aa78ce732a9e62729b5591
Proxy : cal1.iv.ggtyler.dev - refresh the page to change the proxy location
Date : 1733025390412 - unknown on Apple WebKit
Mystery text : U1NVNUdGZ2hqbTAgaSAgbG92ICB1IGNhbDEuaXYuZ2d0eWxlci5kZXY=
143 : true

Naihanchi Comparison - Shorin-Ryu vs KishimotoDi #karate #shorinryu #kishimotodi #kata #martialarts

Jump to Connections

Illinois Practical Karate

4.32K Subs

Download

Redirect!

0 Views • Oct 26, 2024 • Click to toggle off description

This is a side-by-side comparison of the Naihanchi Shodan kata of Chibana-lineage Shorin-Ryu and the Tachimura no Naihanchi kata of KishimotoDi. Because KishimotoDi is a Shuri-Te system, rather than karate, it is effectively an ancestor to modern Shorin-Ryu systems, and does not move in the same ways modern karate does, nor does it adhere to modern karate aesthetics. This often leads to people mistakenly believing that this softer style is weak, or "bad karate." I encourage all karateka to look at the differences and similarities through the lenses of shoshin (beginner's mind) and on ko chi shin (study the old to understand the new), rather than simply rejecting it for not looking like what you expect karate to be. I have personally found the study of this rare, dying art to have enriched my understanding of Shorin-Ryu, and I believe it is something all practitioners of Shuri-Te-based styles should study.

Metadata And Engagement

Views : 0
Genre: Sports
Uploaded At Oct 26, 2024 ^^

warning: returnyoutubedislikes may not be accurate, this is just an estiment ehe :3
Rating : 0 (0/0 LTDR)

0% of the users lieked the video!!
0% of the users dislieked the video!!
User score: 0.00- Overwhelmingly Negative

RYD date created : 2024-10-26T14:56:05.140471Z
See in json

6 Comments

@rreith
1 month ago

I don't understand the level changes in the Kishimoto Di version. Why the bouncing movement? Thank you.

1 |

@hawk0master
1 month ago

Hy, ich will diese Kampfkünste nicht schlecht machen, ich respektiere jeden Kampf Stil so wie er ist. Aber ich kann mir nicht helfen, als Shotokan Karate Ka sieht die KishimotoDi Version einfach.. Lasch aus.. Es fehlt mir die Körperspannung, Struktur und Kime.. Aber ich denke, was mich so irritiert hat ist wohl die übermäßige Kopf und Körper Bewegung es sieht einfach unsauber aus..
Die Shorin-ryu Version ist genau das Gegenteil davon. Saubere Techniken, mehr Kraft mehr Struktur, aber ich finde wenn hier die Fuss Stellung Kiba dachi, breiter und tiefer wäre würde es noch schöner aussehen. Vor allem da dieser mehr an den Shotokan Kata "Tekki Shodan" heran kommt. Dazu kann ich nur ein Video von Shihan Kanazawa Soke 10.Dan empfehlen!

Unabhängigkeit meiner Kritik gegenüber den beiden Stilen, schönes Video und sauber ausgeführte Katas! 👍

|

Go To Top

AutoPlay:

check these out !!!

34:58

52 Masters : Shorin Ryu Karate w/ Shihan Jerry Otto

Kaizen Dojo Films: Motivational Martial Movies

4.1K views

14:43

Karate or Wing Chun? | Naichanchi Shodan for Comparison

Len Tran

6.7K views

04:41